Father Joseph’s
Battle
In a small classroom in the
basement of the Church of St. Teresa, we introduce ourselves to Father Joseph,
a Chinese priest in the Lower East Side. Father Joseph begins by illustrating
his long battle with the Chinese government: he was originally prohibited from
returning to China after he travelled to Rome to become a priest. His
experience reflects the experience of many due to the communist government’s
interference with religion, specifically Catholicism, in China.
“The government does not want the
people to believe in god because they
want to be the god,” says Father Joseph, explaining its control over religious
institutions. According to the New York Times, “China and the Vatican have not
had formal ties since 1951” when Mao Zedong expelled the papal nuncio,
essentially the vatican’s foreign ambassador, to Hong Kong. Because of its
split from the Vatican, the Chinese government created the Chinese Catholic
Patriotic Association, which began to take on duties usually taken on by the
pope. The association mandates church law and appoints bishops based on government’s approval, not the Pope’s, leading
to the Vatican’s excommunication of several bishops. In Chinese law, it is
illegal to teach children under 18 about God and Jesus and it is illegal for
three or more believers to gather for religious purposes without government
approval.
Due to these strict regulations, a
plethora of unofficial churches began to form in order to practice Catholicism
in correspondence with Vatican law, not Chinese law. Currently, “the official
Chinese Catholic Patriotic Church has nearly six million adherents, but some
experts say the number of Chinese Catholics practicing in unofficial churches
is twice that.” As a result of the
government’s attempts control Catholicism by establishing regulations,an entire
network of underground churches has formed, operating completely independently.
“Catholics do not want to practice in China if they cannot have religious
freedom,” says Father Joseph. Therefore, Catholic Chinese are pulled to America
both to escape religious persecution and to freely practice religion.
When they come to America, Father
Joseph is waiting with open arms. He delivers masses and leads religious
education in three Chinese dialects and assists his parishioners with their
assimilation into the community. He talks about how many immigrants come here alone,
and how many Chinese-- 60%-- speak English less than very well. Because they
are sometimes unfamiliar with American culture and New York City life, St.
Teresa provides a place for Chinese immigrants to congregate and practice their
faith in an uninhibited, familiar way. Not only does it provide support for
current Catholics, but it also instills faith in first generation immigrants
experiencing culture shock. For an immigrant having to work 10 hours a day, 6
days a week, a church service can be his only opportunity to relax, reconnect
with his culture, and create connections with others in the same situation. For
an isolated immigrant in an unfamiliar country, churches like Saint Teresa can
be an invaluable resource.
My old religion teacher used to spend his summers smuggling bibles and other religious texts into China, completely illegally. It's interesting to see what kind of freedoms other countries have, as well as what what kind of freedoms we think we have.
ReplyDeleteWhat are the implications if a Chinese person chooses to practice Catholicism in the black market of churches? What will their punishment be?
ReplyDeleteIf they are discovered, it's an illegal act like any other. Off to jail with you!... is all I really can assume. But great question. I'll have to look into it more. It can be a tricky thing to research considering it's one of China's more controversial laws.
DeleteFather Joseph and articles i read said that a lot of the punishment is up to the village chief, but often it is jail.
DeleteInteresting article! Does the communist Chinese government intervene in other religions like Buddhism, Shenism, and Taoism? Why or why not? Does the Chinese government have something against Catholicism?
ReplyDeleteWell, no Chinese citizen is allowed to practice or choose a religion until they are 18 years old because the government wants Chinese citizens to place the government at the top of their list instead of a God. They do not intervene so strongly in any other religion because they are Eastern religions--and there are Catholic churches in China, but they practice a "Chinese" version of Catholicism with elected Chinese bishops instead of following the Roman pope and Roman methods. The main thing about Catholicism is that it is a very Western religion.
DeleteThe Chinese government bans religion to eliminate any competition. They want to be God in the minds of the people they rule over. In China, it's all about power and what's best for the country, regardless of negative consequences to the environment, people, etc. Thus, they employ strict regimentation in regards to everything from religion to free speech.
ReplyDeleteIt's a very corrupt, suffocating system, yet the stories of how people have found ways around these laws to still exercise their rights is really remarkable.
What are the ramifications if these underground churches get found out?
Love your comment, Kyra. Wish I had seen it before responding to Jorge's--it completely answers his questions in a more succinct manner than I did.
DeleteAnd like I said to Kelly, I'm actually not entirely sure what the punishment is. My guess is jail, for the law against religion is just like any other law, but the Chinese government is also a relatively seedy system. It's a difficult thing to research, but I'll look into it and see if I can dig up some answers.
I am wondering how hard it is for a religious practicing chinese person to come to America? Does the government allow them to leave the country with out explanation? How does this work?
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading this article, I am also curious, like Kelly, what is their punishment if caught illegally practicing their religion?
It's not any more difficult than immigrating from China to the U.S. for any other reason (assuming that the government has not found out about their underground religious practices). I mean, people can lie, too. I'm sure a lot of Chinese immigrants did not place religious reasons as the reasons for their immigration. My dad had to lie about his birthplace to actually get a Chinese visa this past summer because he was born in Taiwan, and the embassy did not particularly enjoy that. The Chinese government is a shady one. Plus, many Chinese immigrants come to the U.S. and try to get asylum. If Father Joseph deems an immigrant a "true" Catholic and decides to help them attain asylum, many immigrants work hard and put their money into getting a good lawyer.
DeleteAnd I replied to Kelly's comment! I don't really have a good answer for that question, I'm sorry! If anyone else knows, help me out?
I don't think that you're required to identify your religion when you are emigrating, so I don't think that being Catholic puts up any extra barriers, unless you've been caught, in which case you are probably in jail. It is a very expensive process to leave China, but it is possible, and I do not think it is that challenging as long as you have the resources to leave.
DeleteThat makes sense, thanks for the reply!
DeleteI wonder why the immigrants come here "alone", what does that mean? --- do they come just by themselves or do they come with their families.
ReplyDeleteA lot of immigrants do actually come here completely alone. They do not bring their families over until they feel they can financially support them in the U.S. (and until then, send money back to China) or they come here alone intending to start families in NYC.
DeleteI wonder if these underground Catholic churches have any differences in doctrine with Catholic churches else where in the world. They lack direct oversight by the Vatican which may lead to an interesting blend of traditional Chinese values into one of the oldest western religions.
ReplyDeleteThe non-underground Catholic churches completely differ from Catholic churches elsewhere in the world. If you'd like to read what I said about that, it's in a response I gave to Jorge's comment on this article.
DeleteIn terms of the underground Catholic churches, I think they try their best to be as similar to the churches elsewhere and that's why they have to remain underground. I sort of touched on this in the same reply to Jorge's, but I'll admit that I don't know too much about Catholicism and how the overseeing by the Vatican works. If someone is Catholic, mind explaining what that means for me?
"They lack direct oversight by the Vatican which may lead to an interesting blend of traditional Chinese values into one of the oldest western religions."
DeleteThought-provokin'.
These underground churches could employ some wack ideals into their practices. Not only could they compose a mixture of Chinese and Catholic values, but also a weird blend of values completely fabricated by the persons involved.
Scientology anyone?
This touches on some of my premises - religion is a facet of people's imaginations, a way for them to reconcile themselves with the world they inhabit. So, why restrict it so harshly, Chinese government?
DeleteIt's interesting to think that many people flee to USA for religious freedom and make it a large part of their life. But it makes me wonder about 2nd generation. We've seen how certain aspects of a culture are very important to 1st generation immigrants (especially religion) and that by the time it gets to the 2nd generation it starts to get lost. I wonder if that aspect of religion remains more in the Chinese community in newer generations due to the fact that that is what drove the 1st generation to immigrate in the first place.
ReplyDeleteI would imagine it to be the same as any other religious family. How do children become religious, anyway? Their parents take them to church and some families put their kids in Sunday school--they're taught to believe this at very young ages. I don't think that religion could be lost between generations solely because someone was born in a different country than another. I think religion is an entity which transcends countries of origin.
DeleteHow common is Christianity in the Chinese community?
ReplyDeleteVery.
Delete