Chinese: Assimilation

Chinese Cultural Assimilation


In the 19th Century, Chinese immigrants flocked to America in in hope of the profit and riches the California Gold Rush could offer. They worked diligently alongside Americans as they constructed the Transcontinental Railroad, mined for gold, and worked to expand the nation. However, the Chinese laborers found themselves suffering racial discrimination for taking over the jobs of the white working class because of their willingness to work for longer hours and lower wages. Newspapers and tabloids criticized employers and the government for allowing the Chinese to dominate the laboring job market. Many American journalists created propaganda through political cartoons, and posters, and many drawings and pictures depicted the Chinese as sinister and ugly, with evil expressions, long nails, and the queue hairstyle. One caricature entitled “The Yellow Terror In All His Glory” portrays an evil Chinese man who is stepping on a women, and bears american weapons. Another political cartoon titled “ The Coming Man” displays a grotesque Chinese man maliciously stretching out his hand (stamped with the word “monopoly”) taking over numerous American jobs.

Already it had become apparent that the Chinese were not welcome in American society. This friction between races prompted America to issue their first quota that discriminated against a single ethnicity: the Chinese Exclusion Act. Although many Chinese resented this act, there were only a few rebellions; for the most part the Chinese remained quiet. In addition, the few Chinese that were allowed immigrate were treated awfully. Their customs and traditions were insulted, and many Chinese were imprisoned and beaten, and in the worst cases some were even killed. 60 years later, when World War II broke out, China became an important ally of America against the axis aggressions. During the war famous advertisement of a chinese man campaigned the slogan “This man is your friend : CHINESE : he fights for freedom.” As the war tensions between races relaxed, the Chinese Exclusion Act was finally repealed by President Roosevelt in 1943. However, the amity would soon come to an end when the Peoples’ Republic of China took over the Chinese government converted them to Communism. This brought even more hostility than there was originally. Assimilation was clearly not a feasible option for Chinese Americans. With very limited options, the Chinese began to band together and found villages in cities known as Chinatowns. At first, a Chinatown was a place where the Chinese could establish their cultural community among allies and band against outside discrimination. Soon after Chinatowns began to appear, Americans quickly began to market them as tourist attractions. As seen in the Museum of Chinese-Americans, images of Chinatown were altered to make the location seem more authentic. Non-Chinese residents were edited out of photos and any English text on signs would be replaced with rough Chinese translations. Chinatown transformed from strictly a safe Chinese cultural haven to a tourist enterprise, feeding the American need for something different and exotic. Although many Chinese-Americans have drastically adapted to American culture and society, those living in Chinatown still hold on to many of their own cultural traditions. While New York City takes one day to celebrate the Chinese New Year, celebrations and festivals carry on for an entire week in Chinatown. In addition, the New York Chinese Cultural Center is one of the many institutions in Chinatown that strives to preserve Chinese culture in younger Chinese-Americans through educational programs, dance workshops, and other culture-based activities. When we visited the NYCCC we met Judy, who shared her story of her parents’ journey to America from China and their adaptation to the American culture. Judy’s father worked as a delivery man and waiter at a Chinese restaurant when he first came here, a job commonly equated with Chinese-Americans. These Chinese work stereotypes came from Chinese immigrants isolating themselves in Chinatown from other work opportunities, because of their limited skill sets and language barriers. Along with skewing the portrayal of Chinatown, Americans began to shape other aspects of Chinese culture as well. Shawna, the tour guide in the Museum of Chinese American, described how films began to include “Chinese” characters who were really played by American actors made up to resemble the stereotypical Chinese man or woman.

Today, the Chinese still live somewhat isolated from their fellow New Yorkers, occupying Flushing, Chinatown, and other small neighborhoods. Their culture may have become more Americanized over the years, but it has become the norm to be a tourist in places such as Chinatown. Traditions may be somewhat different, but they are still Chinese in origin. The Chinese may live in their own neighborhoods, but they live united as a population.

15 comments:

  1. I really liked this article, I found it interesting and informative. It left me wanting to know more about the Chinese assimilation.

    Was there originally a lot of immigration to New York City from China, or was it all to the West Coast?
    Why did the Chinese move to the East Coast after the Gold Rush?
    What role do you think stereotypes play in the lives of Chinese-Americans today?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Additionally, why would the Chinese come to New York? what was the pull for them to come here? and how does Chinese Assimilation comparing to other races?

      Delete
    2. There was a quote in one of our readings (I can't remember which one) that said, "If you love your daughter, send her to New York City--it is heaven. If you hate your daughter, send her to New York City--it is hell.". In my opinion, I think this quote does a really good job at trying to get at why Chinese people would immigrate to New York.

      California was majorly the place to be during the Gold Rush, but after that ended, California became just as opportunistic for jobs as any other state with large cities, arguably even less so because so many Chinese were already in California. New York City was still a city of opportunity as it is today, and opportunity is what attracts Chinese immigrants, just like any other. As to whether they choose California over NYC, I can't think of any other reason simpler than it just boiling down to preference.

      You can read more about assimilation in our food article. I'm running out of time.

      Delete
    3. Also, because there was such racial discrimination in California after the railroad completion, many immigrants fled east in the hopes of finding more welcoming areas. Adding on to this, people are attracted to places where people already are, so after the initial formation of Chinatowns in the east, specifically in NYC, it led to more and more people settling in those locations.

      Delete
  2. Although the Chinese live as an "united as a population" in their niche Chinatowns, couldn't this be limiting to the culture? This isolation from the rest of New York prevents any assimilation for the Chinese community into the rest of New York.
    It also intrigues me that these Chinatowns have become tourist attractions to Americans. What are the specific implications of this tourist attraction on Chinese culture? How has Americanization changed the Chinese values? What is still preserved of Chinese culture today?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It definitely is limiting their culture. I think it's true for any immigrant group that has formed a strong community: it helps in the beginning to be among what you know, but it is detrimental as you stay in the same place not learning English and not assimilating to the American culture.


      As for your second point, it's the whole idea that "art imitates life and life imitates art." The Chinese conformed in some ways to the stereotypes given to them by Americans in order to be what American tourists expected of these "exotic" and "foreign" Chinatown's.

      Delete
  3. This article was very thorough, and covered many of the immigration trends and larger ideas we have been discussing in class, as well as those brought up in our readings.

    In the final sentence, you write: "The Chinese may live in their own neighborhoods, but they live united as a population." How has this unity had an effect on the greater city of New York? You seem to imply that this unity is in fact positive, is this true?

    In the Korea group, we often discussed whether or not the isolation, and unification of the immigrant group was holding them back, or making it easy for them to develop in the US, any opinions?

    Finally, how have the Chinese become americanized? For the Korean immigrants we found that the second generation was starkly more "American" than the 1st, was this true for the Chinese?

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the unity is definitely positive in terms of any Chinese immigrants in New York City, regardless of if they live within a Chinatown or not. Reading one of the Mexican articles, that group mentioned that Mexican immigrants are struggling to find support systems within their communities. We found many community centers in Chinatowns that not only helped out their specific community of China town but also received calls to help from outside their neighborhoods and even outside of NYC! In terms of the greater city of New York despite what race you may be, I believe that Chinatowns offer a little pocket of diversity within NYC. NYC, as we have determined, is a conglomerate of many different races, and I think this conglomerate is made only more visible and powerful by all of the little ethnic niches in NYC--Little Senegal, Chinatown, etc.

      Of course the unity of Chinatown can also be seen as a binding thing. One of our sources, Father Joseph, said that many Chinese immigrants do not even step outside of Chinatown. While providing comfort, I am sure it also hinders complete assimilation into American culture.

      Once again, you can read about the Americanization of Chinese immigrants in our food article. Take a look!

      Delete
    2. I definitely think that the second generation is more Americanized than the first, a lot to do with the education system. However, there are several organizations specifically for the cultural education of second, third, etc. generation Chinese-Americans. So while they are more Americanized, there are definitely opportunities to hold onto their original culture, which seems to me to be a very important aspect of Chinese and all immigrant's lives.

      Delete
  4. This article did a really good job illustrating the difficulties of assimilation and specifically how the Chinese immigrants responded to these hardships, which says a lot about the group as a whole. It was especially interesting that you described why stereotypes came about although I think that there were reasons other than isolation and work specialties.
    I think you could have included more specific personal stories from interviews or personal experiences in Chinese neighborhoods. Right now this article is very general and does not seem to pertain to the Chinese community in New York CIty specifically.
    Also, it would be helpful if you split the second paragraph in two just for structural reasons

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you have any ideas of what other reasons could be possible other than isolation and work specialties? You could probably answer you're own question/wondering since you're stating that you think there definitely were.

      Delete
    2. your* That's embarrassing.

      Delete
  5. Both Chinese and Senegalese isolate themselves within small communities. Why?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To Anonymous (whomever you are),
      Although I am not apart of the Chinese group, I also noticed this pattern in Chinese, Senegalese, Mexican, and Korean groups. My hypothesis is this:
      When immigrating the the United States, immigrants often stick with what they know, therefore, ethnic communities stick together to create a foundation in a new and unfamiliar place. Few of us can understand the emotional toll that moving from an entirely unfamiliar country might have on a person, and so although we (particularly I have made this argument multiple times) may argue that ethnic grouping is detrimental to the development of a community, if that is the way immigrants cope with what is foreign to them then so be it.

      Delete
  6. I really liked how much historical information you had. It was very interesting and helped a lot to understand why things are the way they are now. You said that when the Chinese Exclusion Act was passed, "for the most part the Chinese remained quiet". I am curious about why--- I guess it's hard to rebel or protest in a new country, but it seemed like they stayed quiet through a lot of injustices done them. It was cool how this article related to the first one about religion and the last one about food-- you related religion and food in with the whole idea. In the food one, I think you brought up a very interesting point of how Chinese are the Chinese people living in America, saying “If fortune cookies are not really Chinese, then am I really Chinese?”

    ReplyDelete